A virtual wellness program offered by the National Institute for Fitness and Sport and provided to you through your employer.


HomeAsk the ExpertHealth CoachingMotivation WebsiteProgram CalendarWellness Library

 

Sugar and Sugar Substitutes

Sugar is a pure carbohydrate, an important nutrient that supplies energy to the body.  Sugars and starches occur naturally in many foods that also supply other nutrients, like milk and milk products, fruit, bread, cereals, grains, and most vegetables.  Foods containing naturally occurring sugars can be included in a well-balanced diet when consumed in moderation.

Sugar plays an important role in making foods taste better.  It does more than add a sweet taste:

  • Sugar helps bread rise by "feeding" the yeast required in bread making.

  • Sugar is responsible for the even browning of baked goods.

  • In jams and jellies, sugar helps prevent yeasts and molds from growing once the jar has been opened and exposed to air.

  • Frozen and canned fruits keep their vibrant color with the help of sugar syrups that reduce oxidation and browning.

  • Sugar contributes body and texture to ice cream, beverages, baked goods, and other products.  The smoothness of ice cream and sorbet is the work of sugar--it blocks large ice crystals from forming.

  • Condiments like salad dressing and ketchup need a little sugar to offset their acidity and balance their flavor

Sugar provides 15 calories per teaspoon, which is not a significant amount.  However, in the recent past, there has been a huge increase in the amount of sugar consumed by Americans.  This leads to the consumption of too many calories and contributes to weight gain and obesity.  The majority of these additional calories come from added sugars.  Added sugars are sugars and syrups added to foods during processing and preparation.  This is in addition to the naturally-occurring sugars already present, and can add a great deal of calories to the food item. 

 

When looking at a food item, you can identify if there are naturally-occurring and/or added sugars used in the food’s preparation by looking at the ingredient label; however, you cannot distinguish between the two.  Words that end in “-ose” indicate that sugar is present in that food item.  Most often you will see glucose, sucrose (table sugar), fructose, lactose (milk sugar), or maltose where sugar is present.  In recent years, you can find sugar alcohols that supply a very low amount of calories compared to regular sugars.  They are sorbitol, xylitol, and mannitol.     

Sugar Substitutes or Non-Calorie Sweeteners 

If you are looking to lower the calories of your favorite sweet-treats, without giving up the sweet, the FDA has approved the use of several non-calorie sweeteners that may do just the trick.  Most non-calorie sweeteners are man-made chemicals that provide only the sweet taste to foods.  However, when trying to substitute the non-calorie sweetener for sugar in your recipe, you will find that the substitute does not have the chemical food properties found in natural sugar.  Your bread may not rise, and your ice cream may have an odd texture.  This shouldn’t frustrate you; however, read the tips below for answers to your questions.

  • Saccharin - Can be used in hot and cold foods to sweeten them.  Rumors exist that claim this sweetened causes cancer.  The studies performed on saccharin found that very large amounts of saccharin, the equivalent of 875 bottles of diet soft drink per day in humans, does cause cancer in rats.  You will find that this rate of consumption is impossible to attain!  Evidence from other studies performed on humans suggests that saccharin does not cause cancer in humans.  Refer to this website for further details: www.saccharin.org.

  • Aspartame - "NutraSweet" - Only a tiny amount is needed to add a powerful punch of sweetness.  This substitute can be used in baking, but can be altered by high temperatures.  Check out the NutraSweet website at www.nutrasweet.com for answers to your baking questions.

  • Acesulfame Potassium - "Sweet One" - Used in baking and cooking as well as in colder treats.  The texture of products using this substitute may be altered. To reduce the texture changes, it may be best to use some of the real sugar in the original recipe.  Check out www.sweetone.com for more suggestions.

  • Sucralose - "SPLENDA" - Sucralose can be substituted in any sugar-containing food product, including baked goods, processed foods, cold foods, and drinks.  Unlike the others listed above, SPLENDA is made from natural sugar, not man-made, but slightly altered at the molecular level.  Thus, it tastes much like sugar and maintains the same chemical properties.  Additionally, it does not have an aftertaste like the others.  SPLENDA is sold in granular form in large boxes or in small packets.  Use the following tips when preparing foods with SPLENDA this holiday season or check out the SPLENDA website at www.splenda.com.

    • To successfully incorporate SPLENDA granular into a recipe, either combine it thoroughly with the other dry ingredients, dissolve it in liquid, or cream it with butter or other fat sources used in the recipe.

    • In cakes, for every 1-cup of SPLENDA granular, add 1/2 cup nonfat dry milk powder (sifted) and 1/2 tsp baking soda and add to the other dry ingredients.

    • If a recipe calls for sifting all the dry ingredients, measure SPLENDA granular first before sifting.

    • In bar cookies, brownies, muffins, and quick breads, add 1/2 tsp baking soda for every 1 cup SPLENDA granular used in the recipe.  Check for doneness 3-5 minutes earlier than the recipe recommends in these products.

    • In muffins and quick breads, you may add 1-2 Tbsp of honey or molasses to add more flavor and moistness to the recipe.

    • When a recipe calls for beating butter, sugar, and eggs together, you may have to beat the ingredients longer when you substitute SPLENDA for sugar to provide for a more fluffy and even texture.

    • Baked goods made with little or no sugar will not brown.  If you add 1 Tbsp molasses for every cup of SPLENDA granular used, browning will be achieved.

    • When SPLENDA is used in fruit fillings, pudding, and custards, the product may not be as thick, they may cook a little faster, and you may consider adding 1/2 tsp vanilla or almond extract for added flavor.

    • You should check your baked products for doneness earlier than normal when you substitute SPLENDA for sugar.  Check cakes 7-10 minutes earlier and cookies 1-2 minutes earlier.

Using Spices as Sweeteners

Spices can also help to bring out the natural sweet flavors in foods.  See the tips below! 

  • Add ginger to a fruit glaze and toss it with fresh fruit.

  • Add cinnamon to cooked cereals and fruits.

  • Add nutmeg to cookies or rice dishes.

  • Spice up ground coffee before brewing with cinnamon, ginger, mace, nutmeg, and/or allspice.

  • Add a touch of vanilla extract to sweeten coffee, puddings, and your favorite baked goods.

  • Seasoning carrots with ginger or using cinnamon in your sweet potatoes could be key to enticing your kids’ taste buds for veggies.

  • Experiment with flavors by adding SMALL amounts of spices or vanilla to maximize and enhance taste.

Sources:  www.eatright.org; www.diabetes.org; www.caloriecontrol.org/lowcal.html; www.sugarsavvy.org